‘Cult’ – Initial Review


Chance it.

Dave’s 4-Word Review:
Captivating, Intriguing, and Original

As a general rule, I’ve always been a strong supporter and fan of self-aware television shows and movies. By self-aware, I mean shows within a show, or a movie within a movie. This may have been brought on by Arnold Schwarzenegger’s 1993 hit film, “Last Action Hero”, where Arnie plays himself, as well as his character on screen when a young boy is thrown into the theater’s screen via a magic movie ticket. How about in “New Nightmare”, the final film in the original “Nightmare on Elm Street” where the character of Freddy Krueger comes to our world and wreaks havoc on the original cast members of the first film. That is so amazing. I loved that movie, and I love it whenever a show or movie decides to do something like it. Amazingly, this is a rare concept. It is a concept that CW’s new show, “Cult” has decided to use.

The first episode opens up following around the life of Billy Grimm (Robert Knepper), who is obviously the leader of a cult that is planning something terrible. Basically, no one understands why, but when someone utters a phrase, they end up killing themselves uncontrollably. For the first few minutes, this is what we understand, and we really don’t know what to think of the show yet, until it zooms out and we see the credits roll for CW’s popular show, “Cult”, on a TV in the show itself, with people watching. Mind blown, I personally am already hooked because that is the kind of concept I am interested in. The show goes on to introduce us to Matthew Davis, who plays Jeff Sefton, a man whose brother just went missing…supposedly at the hands of this strange TV show. A conspiracy seems to boil up, and it unwraps more questions as it continues.

I both love the show and fear for it for a number of reasons. I love it, because there are so many possibilities to use with the concept. I wanted “Last Action Hero” to get a sequel or release an extended version, or something else where the movie wouldn’t end. There is so much undiscovered territory around the idea alone. At the same time, this can be a terrible, terrible thing.  Undiscovered also means that they haven’t found the flaws. This means the show can be huge if people gave it a chance, and if it went down the right path, but it could also be a terrible failure if they take a single wrong turn.

The acting isn’t half bad. Right now, only Knepper seems to shine bright as the memorable actor. This may be because of his character’s mysterious nature, but Knepper is pretty known to hold at least a moderate level of memorableness. The rest of the cast have a bit to go before people will be able to picture their faces in their mind without looking at pictures. That can be a problem for some, maybe not for others. Basically, what you have to do here, is just….give the show a chance.

All in all, this is a tremendous risk for CW. It seems to be right in their alley, and their fans would certainly love it. Robert Knepper has always had a knack for being creepy, and his efforts shine bright still. The only question that remains here is if this big risk also means a big reward, or if it means going into a show while blind?  Honestly, only time can tell as the show has only aired but two episodes. So far, it remains intact and intriguing, so here’s to hoping it continues on that path, and doesn’t trip all over itself (as some CW shows have had the misfortune of doing).



5 thoughts on “‘Cult’ – Initial Review”

  1. I WAS going to check it out, but then I saw the Nielsen ratings. Typically most shows need a rating of over 1.5-2.0 to avoid getting canceled. On CW this is more around 1.0, but this show got a 0.3. It’s probably the lowest rated show I’ve ever seen, and that was the pilot, which for most shows is one of their higher rated episodes.

    1. Wow, I still say check it out, because it is incredibly original. Like I said, some actors have a bit to go in order to get to Knepper’s area, but it has some serious potential. If it gets cancelled, It would be another Journeyman thing

      1. Journeyman played all their episodes. With this it’s unlikely it’ll play more than 2 unless the new episode gets an exceptional ratings boost.

      2. Journeyman didn’t go out on their own, it was cancelled, and it was a great show. It had so much to offer and left with so many unanswered questions. It would have went on for a while if they didn’t get the boot. That’s what I’m getting at. Potential.

  2. It got canceled but they played all the episodes they made, which was something like 10-13 episodes. This show will be lucky if it gets another. CW is notoriously generous, but I don’t know how far that goes,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s